I'm sort of in the same situation myself.

Actually, I get shit for it from my team, but they're like my brothers so I know its all in good fun and because its pretty much one of the only things that separate me from them (apart from my rocking good 2k times on the erg).

I think just most people find it different and I've had some girls who've straight up asked me if I have a birth defect on my dick as my foreskin doesn't retract when I get a boner.