Guys:Whats the first thing you notice in a Guy

Face and Chest, if he is shirtless

face, clothes, body (if you notice the clothes first, it's kinda fun to be imagining what's underneath it all)

The first thing would be height. I have a Napoleon complex even at my height.
Next would be face - eyes, bone structure, ergo - is this guy 'better bred than me', then body, then personality. Ability to exchange pointed, witty conversation and joke also at the top of the list.
It is natural to size up the competition so to speak and see if there is the same goal in mind. Guys seem to get on better when there is not the same end goal in mind and they are able to relate on an equal plane.

Absolutely! It's the best!

Eyes, hair and body shape.

Is it bad to say wallet?

The eyes do it for me

eyes, nose, lips, chin, shape of face, body size then voice/accent. let's be honest here, cock or buldge is the first reason why i started looking in the first place

The face and the physique. I like tall, lean men that tend towards olive or darker complexion who do not shave their body hair.

The ass. I always wonder how a guy's ass looks. I also love eyes and skin. I notice skin because I love when it is smooth and flawless. Not a blemish in sight.

Teeth is the first thing that I look for and notice on a guy. I'm all about good teeth. Then it's nice shoulders, great legs, round butt, and pray that he has a personality.

Posture
Gait
Energy level and Presence
Accent and Quality of Voice
General hygiene

oh my. What a assortment of responses

eyes, smile, arms