Crazy Story: What are the odds?

You are being paranoid. He informed matt6046 he's a married closeted bisexual. Hence they already know about the risk of being caught. From the family photos matt would be able to recognize his buddy's family members on sight. That matt knew the daughter previously is but another secret that these two could share and discuss.

I still havn't said anything to him. He's e-mailed me a few times since, I think he's hoping to meet up again.

I definitely don't HAVE to ever meet him again. Before I found out I knew his daughter, I figured I'd meet him again at some point. The sex was hot. Plus in a small town the chances of meeting anyone else is small (let alone someone my age). Still, I think it's weird if I continue to sleep with my friends father.

well it is small town rural America.

Greek Dude-you are not evil. That story is totally hot.
Matt6046-you said the sex was hot and in your community, there aren't many other options to choose from. The devil on my shoulder is advising you to bang away, but you'll have to let him know about the relationship with his daughter. Something tells me that while he may be surprised, he won't wanna stop...

Fair enough but that is why I wrote "may". Any number of things could result, although I tend to err on the side of caution. If the father finds out about the connection, then he might continue to worry that at some point the secret will be revealed, the chances of it happening increase.

Also, can you imagine if the friend ever finds out? Assuming the parents are still together, the friend will consider the guy to be "other woman" who stole her dad away or confused him. So in one fell swoop the father is bisexual, an adulterer and someone who sleep with someone the daughter's own age. That's a bit much for anyone I think.

It's a shame the guy has so little options in his home town but I can relate and that's why I was thrilled to leave mine.

Assuming the parents are still together dad hasn't been stolen by anyone.
She wouldn't think dad was confused by matt. Naturally she would be upset about them having sex and wonder if her parents would divorce over this issue.

Small communities = everyone knows everyone else. Chances of being found out are big in a small town.