jelquing vs pumping

From what I understand, jelquing forces the blood to expand the penis plus the stretching action also increases length. But, pumping does both of these but at a continual rate and without all the exercise. So shouldn't pumping bring the same or better results?

jelquing? now that's a new one on me. I have never heard that term before. Can anyone go into greater detail and enlighten me? Thanks!

You're kidding

no, I'm not.

use the search function then ;)
1000's of threads about it.


on topic:
I don't think pumping has the same effects until you do it hardcore, which may cause disproportion of your unit.

Reading in another website, they say that jelquing is permanent and pumping is not.

I Am Pumping For 3 Years, Ones A Week For 1 Hour
Mine Was 19,2 Cm , Now It Is 21,6 Cm , So It Works

yes!pumping definately works!all it takes is devotion.

Neither of the gains from jelqing or pumping is very permanent. My size from pumping lasts only days and within a week, the gains are about all gone. Jelqing has a similar period of lasting, jelqing can last longer, but it's effects are not as pronounced as pumping. The squeezing of the blood vessels and capillaries from jelqing can actually be quite damaging if one is too zealous. pumping can wreak havoc on the skin of the penis, but the blood vessels and capillaries stay pretty much safe except for the surface capillaries of the skin, which can get quite boogered up from pumping incorrectly.

The only forms of penile enlargement that are permanent are surgical methods and injecting silicone. Jelqing and pumping are temporary, but weightlifting and body building is temporary... face it, the body goes back to normal no matter what we do to it... if we stop the activity, the benefits of the said activity stop also. They are safe methods and one can jelq succesfully without pumping, but one cannot pump succesfully without jelqing. I lift weights and plan on lifting weights well into my old age... I plan on pumping just as long also, they are both lifetime commitments.

I don't think the results from jelqing are necessarily temporary, plenty of guys report they don't go or all go when they stop. There are ways of 'cementing' gains. I did it a few years ago and the gains haven't disappeared since.

Here is the article:
Penis Pumps: Are They Really Effective for Penis Enlargement?

It defies the laws of nature... the human body will always try to achieve the state of homeostasis, if something rises, it will eventually fall.

Nobody who lifts weights has ever built themselves up to a point where they could just stop lifting because they have "cemented" their gains.

Your theory is just not possible... the smooth muscle cells of the penis do not respond to exercise like skeletal muscle and they do not really enlarge due to jelqing anyway. The skin will shrink back down after you stop jelqing and any vascular improvements that gave you improved circulation will go away also. What the hell is permanent about jelqing? You will have to prove your theory of "cementing" your gains because it is just not scientifically possible.

Well I cannot claim to be an expert on the physiology of this, only what I have experienced and what other guys have reported.

Perhaps muscles are not the best comparison - as far as I know the tribes who stretch their ears, lips, necks etc don't go back to normal after they finish stretching.

They are never finished stretching... they keep the stretching instruments in place for their entire life.

Well traditionally they keep the stretching instruments in because it is part of their decoration and culture, but if they stop due to adopting "modern" ways the results may be permanent.

There is plenty of anecdotal evidence that PE gains can be permanent. Some report losing some but not all gains, others report not losing any at all. I myself did jelqing and other PE exercises four to five years ago but then stopped until recently and in that time did not lose any of the 3/4" gain in length I had.

There is no scientific evidence for PE as far as I know, as it seems no research has ever been done into it - it probably would not be considered respectable to publish in a scientific journal.
However the articleHeat and stretch procedures: an evaluation using rat tail tendon from the Archives of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
does provide evidence of permanent stretch in animal tissues. Heat and stretch procedures: an evaluation using r...[Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1976] - PubMed Result There are also other articles in scientific journals into the permanent stretching of connective tissues etc.