Several times I heard “Is it always that big?”

Also “You’ve must have made a lot of girls happy with that thing!”

“Oh my God have you should be working in porn!”

“You’ve got the biggest dick I ever saw. You’re twice as big as ___ (her ex). I have to measure it.” She ran off and came back with a tape measure. “Oh my God it’s nine and a half inches long. And it’s six and a half inches around! Wow, if I were a boy I’d want to have a dick like that!”

I loved the non-verbal reaction on a girl who jumped back and fell off the bed after she pulled my pants off and my cock sprang up. She then jerked me off for about 10 minutes staring at it with eyes wide muttering, “Oh wow.”

From a girl who had been teasing me for weeks when she finally took me out of my pants, “Oh my God! Is this what I’ve been doing to you?”

After penetration, from several different girls:

I can’t believe you fit inside of me.

Easy! Your dick is huge.

I can’t believe how much you fill me up.

My all time favorite though was when after a night of drinking and flirting, and having skipped any foreplay so she hadn’t seen me before penetration. She said as I entered her “God your dick is big!”

After sex for the first time, very different reactions from different girls:

I can’t believe I let you put that thing in me. My boyfriend is going to kill me.

I wish my ex could have seen that.

I’m going to be lucky if I could still walk tomorrow.

You realize that you ruined me for small dicks now.

And lastly: That’s going to take some getting used to.


First post. Greetings all. Great group.