Quote:
Originally Posted by coolwind My two cents, I am a musician, totally straight, and like some of her work. I also think she is hot, now, then. The thing about her music for me that is least appealing is the tendency to flatten rhythm, you almost always hear her stretching phrases and seldom hitting any kind of interesting rhytmic figure. That's why Billie Holiday would be more likely to be on my CD player, but it's a matter of taste I guess |
Super observation coolwind.
I agree depending on which style is her style of the moment. I find it unfortunate that she attempted too often to follow the trend of the day rather than hold with the genre which suits her best.
It'd be like Whitney wasting her voice on Hip Hop or Rap.
Pity Streisand aborted her innate talent at interpretation of torch song-esque things all through the seventies and well into the eighties.. But she's back now.
She's not rhythmic by inclination. Nor is she a jazz singer. She's a vocalist whose suggestion of and inclination toward pitch perfection (when singing music that suits her best) remains without compare to me. Therein stands her unique talent along with her ability to "melt" a note into the orchestration.
In the last clip of hers I've posted she actually appears in a trance-like state as she weaves her voice
around the music. It may well be a taste thing but for my musical ear it's the "stuff" of the angels.
(I like Billy Holiday too but there's a overtly nasal whine that grates after a point with her...)