Best reaction to your size the first time....

"Oh Shit"

"Woah your dick is huge... I knew it was big but not like that"

"Oh my god you have a gorgeous cock. I just want to rub it all over my face."
And then she did. :)

Being of average length, but above average width, I did get the "wow, you can really feel that hitting both sides."

Am impressed I actually managed to finish off after that. Kept on getting the urge to laugh...

Some ive had in the last few years..........

"OMG where have you been hiding that!"
"I thought u had something stuffed down there"
"I'm not used to one this big"
"Your very blessed"
"Thats biggest and hardest cock ive seen"

A few years ago I had a one night stand with a girl I picked up at a dance club.
As we where getting undressed she looked at my cock and said.
I Quote:"Wow your huge,Don't try to put that in my butt!"
Then when we where fucking all she said was :"Oh shit, oh Shit! Your dick is almost to fucking big but don't stop. "
To this day that night brings a smile to my face.

Random hook up in college after being at the bars.

I ate her out then stood up to roll rubbr on my almost 8.5 x 6.5c, her eyes bulged, her jaw dropped, and she goes "fuck that 's bigger than my wrist, please be gentle b/c I'm going to be sore for days."

It was a wild night.

I had a fuck buddy back in high school who moved away for college. When we were a couple years into college he came home to visit and I fucked him in his pickup truck for the first time in two or three years. When got my cock slid up into him he groaned and said something like "ugh, I forgot how fat that thing was."

That would be hot!

the best was my first, when i was 15. she was 14, but already had fucked like 10 guys. she saw my 8 inch thing and was like "holy jesus. put that in me RIGHT NOW!"

She said, "Christ, where did that come from???"

Well, I'm not big, a mere 7" x 5", but I'm a real grower, from near zero to full curved length at the touch of a finger-tip.

You should put some pics in your lpsg gallery!

Well, it was with my boyfriend at the time. He was the biggest I had ever been with. I serioously have never had sex with a penis under 7.5 inches. I don't know how this has happened, but I think I must be a big penis magnet or something, ahah. But my last boyfriend always told me he was huge, and that he had a big dick, and this is was before we were even together. I never believed him, and I always called him a liar, and that the last guy I had been with had a 9 inch cock, and no one would ever be bigger than him. He would always say, oh, well I think my penis might be bigger than that. So one day, when we were "boyfriends", we were going to have sex. I felt his errection through his pants, and it felt pretty damn big, so I was thinking, "uh oh, maybe I should have just believed him, cause now I'm gonna get it". So yeah, it turned out being 10.3 inches and 6.5 inches in girth. So I was shocked, very shocked, and it was pretty painful, like being a virgin again!

"You're DEFINITELY bigger than Zach"

I've gotten "It's nice to finally have a man inside me." Twice WITH TWO SEPARATE GIRLS.

Weird.

"Holy shit, you look practically deformed."

I'd known her for a while, it wasn't a one night stand, and we had an easy, joking relationship, but I'm still not 100% certain you could take it as a compliment.

She then refused to go on till she'd found a ruler and measured it. Which was a good bit more of a turn on than the comment.