Best reaction to your size the first time....

From a fellow like you, I take smiling any sort of sarcasm...

"I'm soaking wet...it looks nice and thick. And well, big! Although size isn't everything...but I bet you know how to use it too"

It is and I do!

Lovely girl.

bump

"Shit, you are not so fucking me with that thing tonight". So I asked him if tomorrow would be a better night, we both laughed and got naked. I did fuck him that night, and he took it all..

This is an awesome thread. It always is a big turn on for me when I get comments about my size. (Although I've never thought I was all that big -- especially compared to some of the pics of you guys in the gallery!!).

The first time a girl commented about my size was when I was in college. I had a quick "nooner" with a girl that I had been flirting with for a while. We were laying side by side under the covers after having sex for the first time. She asked "do you mind if I look at you?" I was in really good shape then & said "sure" thinking that she was going to check out my chest or abs. Instead, she raised up the covers & spent a few seconds looking at my still semi erect cock. She said, "That's beautiful. Do women often tell you that you're well endowed?" I didn't tell her she was the first to say anything like that.

Other comments over the years have been: "You're going to faint with all your blood going to that thing" or "you certainly don't have anything to be embarrassed about in a locker room." I think some women just say things like that as an ego stroke.

The best comment I ever had was when I first had sex with a woman who ended up being a long term gf. She asked me to enter her very slowly. As I slid in about half way she moaned, "mmmmm . . .size does matter!" I almost came right then.

Fascinating thread - lots of posts striking a chord!

What I've found (forgive me if someone has already made this point), is there are three types of girls.

- The ones who don't care you're well-hung, or if they do, they never mention it.
- The ones who are thrilled by it, and mention it on the first date, or soon after (some fantastic comments come to mind). This is the biggest group.
- The ones who are ABSOLUTELY OBSESSED by it - especially good if it's something they've had in their mind for years and years but never found the right guy! I'm thinking about one girl who adored the size so much she was practically smacking herself in the fucking face with it. Dirty bitch

A group of my friends have a discussion board (not about sex topics) and a few days ago someone posted the article about heidi klum revealing that the first thing that attracted her to seal was his "package" which made her say "wow".

So a few days ago this cute girl who's on that discussion board and I are hanging out and we're talking about haloween costumes (we are at her house). so she suggests I try on this big hair wig and this tight short speedo-type thing to be David Lee Roth.

at first i said i didn't want to but then i decided why not. so i put the wig on and the shorts, and they are tight and it's very clear what I have down there.

so i come out, and this girl gets bright red and so embarrased.

so a while later we're hanging out and i ask if she thinks i'll get girls with that outfit...

she says "oh yeah"

i said "really?"

she goes "all I have to say is this: you remember that post I had about seal and why heidi klum liked him...well, WOW"

Dated a girl in University and when she first saw me naked I was fully erect and her first word was: "Finally!"

I was her tenth lover and she had never had more than 5 inches before I came along.

heh heh... came along... so immature...

Damn! (speechless and nervous eyes)

From your pix, I can see why.

I had an extremely flattering reaction a couple of weeks ago. I have always had a crush on this girl I work with named Charlotte. She had been in like a 4 year relationship with some lame guy, but he broke up with her. Well, it turns out she had always liked me as well, because I quickly became the revenge fuck.
I know this sounds made up, but I swear to god we had sex in a hot tub. She had already made a big fuss about my body, saying (when i took my shirt off): "damn, If I knew you had a body like that I would have cheated on Chris months ago."
So when she pulled down my shorts later in the night, she looked at my dick and really quickly said "holyshit!" She said it like it was one word. Then, she grabbed it, started giggling, and said "You are a fucking greek god."

Talk about a turn on! Stroking my ego while she strokes my cock.

bump

I love how all of our stories sound similar. My favs...

my ex, who was 5' and 95#, pulled off my underwear and gasped, then started laughing. "I didn't expect that!" she said. Later, she told me if I'd been even 1/4" bigger, length or girth, she'd have refused intercourse. The ex and I played with others as well, mostly couples. She kept joking about how women were going to react to my size, but I brushed it off, untiiiil....the first time another woman sucked me with her. I'll never forget the look in her eyes after she tried to get me down her throat but couldn't: Wide-eyed. Another female of a couple, who I wasn't really that into (not my type, but we were all naked. Funny how that works) was fucking her husband and watching my wife suck me. He kept saying, "You want that, don't you? He's big, isn't he?" and she just kpt responding "Yes!". Another time, we swapped with another couple; friends of ours. The wife (a gorgeous redhead) and I made out, and I went down on her for a bit, until she whispered for me to be inside of her, so she never even saw or touched my dong. I slid it in, and she gasped. After about 30 seconds, she asked, "Are you gonna come? Because you're wearing me out!" I saw a glance of her husband's cock, which was rather small-ish. Later, my ex said, "She probably didn't know what hit her!"

With the last couple we swapped with, the wife, and we pounded away at eachother, kept telling me that "your cock is amazing!" Once we were all finished and washing up, her husband looked at my flaccid cock and said, "You fucked my wife with that? Now what am I supposed to do?" We all laughed.

Another girl I dated, while we were making out in her kitchen, knelt down and pulled down my pants. All I heard was, "Oh my God!" in a whisper. I wasn't even fully hard yet, so as she took me in her mouth and I grew, she kept stopping, saying, "My God" over and over. Later, when she drove me home, she kept looking over and giggling, then looking at my crotch and repeating "My God!".

Finally, my girlfriend, whom I've been friends with for 9 years and only began dating 1 year ago, our first night together, sat naked on her bed after I tore off her clothing. I got undressed and walked in from the living room, my cock raging hard. She grabbed it with her hands and exclaimed an enthusiastic "Fuck yeah!". To this day, over a year later, she still looks at it and exclaims, "it's so fucking huge!". I had no idea she was a size queen, and she claims, "Neither did I until I started fucking that thing!"

God, I love that woman :)

So I was at a party with my class mates from collage and there was always this little blond girl in the class that was the super innocent kind of personality, She didn't always talk that way or act but the personality vibe was like a cartoon little girl the perfect daughter from some family christmas move made in the 50s. Any way we all were partying pretty pretty hard and her small stature wasn't helping her and she was totalled after about 2 hours and we had to put her in the tub near the toilet. People would watch over and take shifts and what not and after like another 4 hours I had forgot she was ever in the bathroom. It was about 2:30 in the morning and half the party had either fallen asleep or gone home and it was done to the real goers. I had been waiting for what felt like ever to use the up stare bathroom when I could hear the sounds of vommiting inside. I was like not getting in there anytime soon, so I remembered the downstairs one and ran to get to it. I run in and find Stacey (the blond) and this other girl just chilling in the bath room. the other girl was in her bra which immediately drew my attention. She read the look and was like its in the washer stuff got spilled on it. I nodded and was like i see, well I need to take to use the bathroom. The girl was like I Stacey can barely stand and I don't want to see that. Iwas like ummm well she can close her eyes or look away or what ever, and you can wait in the laundry area outside. Stacey was like HE HAS TO PEE let him I won't watch. The other girl Jess was like ooooh kay... and walked out side and yelled but the door doesn't close (I figured she was worried about me assault or doing somthing to Stacey I just really needed to go. So anyways I was definitely at an engorged state but not hard at all and i had to work to get it out. I was to pre-occupied to notice Stacey really wasn't looking away. I got it out and started to urinate when, Stacey lets out a whoop and a cry. I look down at her and shes just smiling leaning on the edge of the tub. She's looks at my dick and says that its a monster. Jess hearing the noise runs in stops and just says holy shit, laughs and stares at Stacey trying to hold up her arm to measure my length along her for arm while I pee. Jess just laughs and Stacey exclaims It's twice Cam's (her boyfriend) i started to blush and laugh awkwardly knowing he was somewhere up stairs. Jess exited the bathroom again and stacey loudly tried to whisper "lorne your girlfriend is lucky your dick is huge, I'm going to ask Cam if you can join us tonight" I was like I don't thin he'd like that (he wouldn't). She just laughed and was like he will if he wants some. I was like well I'm done shows over, and she drunkenly winked and said come back soon. I left and walked past Jess without eye contact. the next day when people were leaving cam and Stacey were getting ready to go and the whole time Cam just glared at me. My buddy asked after they left what that was about. I said to him she saw my dick last night. my buddy was like ALRIGHT! jokingly, I added and I think she told him I'm bigger. the three people in the room made the combined sound similar to that of a goin shot video reaction. We all laughed for a while. After that day she started to refer to me as the dragon with this other guy she was friends with.

I was nineteen the first time I came to Montreal and spoke no French, so I met this guy, we went to his place and when he saw my bit he loudly proclaimed, with much emotional enthusiasm "Aah! C'est gross!"

Well I did not know that in French 'gross' means 'big' and so I thought he was grossed out and so I left - even though he was trying hard to change my mind - the language divide was just too great

well thats probly not the best reaction, but for me at least it was one of the most memorable :)