Best reaction to your size the first time....

A couple of days after we started having sex, she said, with a guilty look, "I told my friend about your size and how we had to find larger-sized condoms. I'm sorry, hope you don't mind..."

You have to understand, this was from a very restrained, classy girl who genuinely felt it wasn't really her secret to pass on, but couldn't contain her excitement, and thus confessed to this serious breach of social etiquette! :-)

First post -- hello to all. Great thread!

"OMG!!!! This will either be heaven or hell!!!"

As I recall, it was heaven.

After some making out with this girl and I got naked, she looked down at my hard cock and said, "Man, am I gonna have me some fun with that dick tonight!!"

The most passionate reaction I got was a girl who was incredibly sensual and outgoing. She got my pants off then gasped, "Oh my god, you're unbelievably huge" in my ear and went wild. That was a good night.

Another time was with a cute little redhead. We were settling into my first (and only) anal experience and it came up whether she'd been with two guys at the same time before. She said, "Yes ...but you're bigger than both of them combined." Also a good night.

This was with a mature ( 40ish), attractive and very big brested woman I had been dancing tango with earlier on in the evening. We get back to her place and things get hot as soon as we closed the front door behind us. First I take off her top and her braw to let out those huge tits. Very nice! Meanwhile, she's feeling up my bulge and getting my belt undone. When she actually got it out there was a slight pause where she alternatly looked up at me and down at my erection a few times. Here eyes were glowing. She took it in her hand and said something along these lines: '' OMG, it's so long. It's beautyful! OMG, I want to feel that inside me, I want you to f--- me with that cock. I hope you don't mind me talking to you this way, it's just that...'' Mind!? Hell no, I loved it. We had a great time. I love it when women get vocal about your size; a real turn on!

Several times I heard “Is it always that big?”

Also “You’ve must have made a lot of girls happy with that thing!”

“Oh my God have you should be working in porn!”

“You’ve got the biggest dick I ever saw. You’re twice as big as ___ (her ex). I have to measure it.” She ran off and came back with a tape measure. “Oh my God it’s nine and a half inches long. And it’s six and a half inches around! Wow, if I were a boy I’d want to have a dick like that!”

I loved the non-verbal reaction on a girl who jumped back and fell off the bed after she pulled my pants off and my cock sprang up. She then jerked me off for about 10 minutes staring at it with eyes wide muttering, “Oh wow.”

From a girl who had been teasing me for weeks when she finally took me out of my pants, “Oh my God! Is this what I’ve been doing to you?”

After penetration, from several different girls:

I can’t believe you fit inside of me.

Easy! Your dick is huge.

I can’t believe how much you fill me up.

My all time favorite though was when after a night of drinking and flirting, and having skipped any foreplay so she hadn’t seen me before penetration. She said as I entered her “God your dick is big!”

After sex for the first time, very different reactions from different girls:

I can’t believe I let you put that thing in me. My boyfriend is going to kill me.

I wish my ex could have seen that.

I’m going to be lucky if I could still walk tomorrow.

You realize that you ruined me for small dicks now.

And lastly: That’s going to take some getting used to.


First post. Greetings all. Great group.

it wasnt the first positive reaction but it was a reaction that gave my dick his first name....

i was with a leather-guy in l.a. and he went down on his knees and opened my trousers and fished all my goodies out and exclaimed: "Jesus!"

so from that time on, to certain friends, my dick i called "baby jesus" because usually he's napping and curled up but sometimes he gets ornery and worked up and kinda scary/awesome, and has to have his way

he got another name in grad school but that's another story.

First time with ex. She pulled it out and said "you have a beautiful penis".

Funniest reaction ever was "your not that John HOlmes guy are you..." LOL, she was a good sport....

oh my god what a fucking big dick (expression) and circumcised to. (grasping it and just squeezing it, looking at it and having fun with it)

Different lines I remember: 'wow', 'is that real?' 'fuck me NOW' - I'm 8 x 5 - but the best was when I dropped 'em in front of a real good-looking but petite chick who said 'Jesus, you'll split me in two!' But I got her pussy nicely wet and had the tightest and best fuck of my life. No way could I get into her ass tho, which was a shame. Just a one-nighter but sticks in my mind.

Where I grew up a lot of guys had big dicks so I never got that much attention for it until college. Still my favorite goes like this:
I was sleeping in my dorm room and my roommate was gone for the weekend, I got a knock at the door and it was a girl I had made out with a few times before. I could tell she had a few drinks in her so I wasn't going to take advantage of that so I just sat on my bed while she sat in a chair and we talked. She blurted out at one point "Do you have a big cock?" to which I gave a surprised "What?!" and she responded with "Well, you're a big guy so I was just wondering if you have a big cock?" I went the easy route and said I didn't know. She told me she would be right back and when she got back to my room had a ruler and a tape measure in her hand with a big grin on her face. So I under the covers measured him because by this point I was getting sort of aroused. So I told her the results, just a hair under 8 long and a little over six around. She scoffed and said I was lying and just as she did i pulled off the blanket. It was like magnets were in her hands. She just reached out for it with both hands and started stroking it. She asked after about 20 seconds if she could touch it...which was obviously a little belated but I naturally said yes. She muttered to herself the whole time things like "so fucking huge" "it's as big as my wrist" "it's making me so wet" "it feels so nice" eventually she asked if she could suck it and the second she put it in her mouth she let out a moan of relief. She fingered herself while sucking me and came quickly. I don't usually cum from blowjobs so i pulled out and then jacked off in her mouth which she absolutely loved. She had a propensity to get drunk a lot and ended up telling everyone on my floor (including the resident advisors) about my cock size, often times right in front of me while grabbing at my package. Really an awesome time.

Others amongst my favorites are:
upon feeling my bulge "What's in your pants!?" and upon seeing it "Oh my god! (covers mouth and then once over the shock sucks it down)

in a hushed tone "Gaawd.." to which I said "what?" and she replied "huh? I didn't say anything" "yes you did, you said god" "Oh (sheepishly)...i didn't mean to say that outloud..it's just...really big"

(feeling me press against her as I'm about to try and go inside of her with no foreplay, looks down) "wow...that's....impressive"

"yes! enough of that small dick shit!" ( I know her ex boyfriend and he is a total ass so this one was personally satisfying on a different level)

"you ARE big aren't you"

"It's the size of the boat! It's the size of the boat!" being screamed while I was giving it to her nice and hard. I love dating girls with a sense of the humor.

My current girlfriend and i met at a haloween party last year and at some point in the drunken revels she mentioned her ex-bf being 4" long. so i replied that i was over twice that size. her immediate response was "There is no way you have a 9" cock!!!" i just laughed and moved on. later that night when we got back to my apartment she took off my pants, gasped and said "wow!! boy was i wrong! can i put my mouth on it?"
we are still together and it turns out that even though she had had sex with 5 guys before me her hymen had never been broken. when we first had sex she started bleeding and freaked out because she couldnt figure out what was going on. but afterwards we had the best sex ever because she has the deepest vagina i have ever been with and can just barely fit my entire cock. she just never knew about the upper 3" of her pussy.

Um, judging by your name, and that you found that line humorous, did she happen to be you cox'n?