Best reaction to your size the first time....

reddog

that kind of says it all, right lapdog? Group?

just me

I would have to give three different reactions:
First - the whore who took my cherry "Oh your're one of those guys who was suppose to be borne with three legs."
Second - the girl whose cherry I took "Is that suppose to fit?"
Third - my wife on our honeymoon night " Damn how the hell do you hide that damn drawbridge?"

niko

Several quotes to share:

One girl: "Hmmm, looking at your dick is a foreplay for me." (my favourite)

Another girl: "Now that's what I call a good size."

Another girl: "You're huge."

One man:"Dude, you have to let me suck that thing."

Honey_Grrrl83

The first time I saw my fiance's erect penis was just before we had sex for the first time,he was taking a shower,and I saw the outline of his hard on through the shower curtain I lost my virginity to him three days later,I was going to wait until my wedding night but after I saw that glorious sight I coulden't wait All I said to him was,"That's impressive baby,why didn't you tell me about it?"
He said,"I didn't want to frighten you off".
"Frighten me off? You've got to be kidding!"I replied

Okay,I'm back

likes natural wonders

I try to let it be known how happy I am. My first stallion had told me he was 8X6 online before we met. I think the first thing I said was wow you certainly are big (thats how he described himself "big"), then I had to follow it up with "wow, lucky me, lucky me, lucky me" GULP!

art

My first gf who was my age (I lost my virginity to, and enjoyed sex with, women in their 20s and 30s, when I was 15 and 16. They didn't have too much to say...guess they'd seen their share of big cocks) and I were kissing and making out one afternoon in her living room. We were supposed to have been studying US History. She'd unbuttoned my shirt, and pulled it from my jeans; I'd discarded her shirt and bra, and was having a great time kissing and sucking on her breasts.

She pushed me back against the sofa, and I leaned myself on my elbows to watch as she opened my belt, and unbuttoned my jeans. The bottom two or three inches of the shaft of my brief-encased dick sort of "popped up" into the opening of my fly. She gasped, then licked her lips. She slid her hand beneath the Jockey waistband, grabbed hold of my dick, and pulled it upright so it stood against my abs. Her eyes got real big, and she said "I can't believe it's that big. You've got SUCH a fat dick!" Then she started licking around the head, and gently put it in her mouth, and sucked more and more of it into her mouth. I lust lay back and enjoyed it. Eventually I peeled down my jeans and briefs, helped her get naked,and enjoyed a few hours of hot sweaty sex that afternoon. We got dressed about a minute before her mom got home from work. She wondered why we looked so hot, flushed, and happy.

mlc808

I've gotten some interesting responses because of thickness (very) vs. length (just average).

While getting a blowjob "I don't think I could have sex with you." She did.

Her friend who she told about it when she saw it later (she followed me into the bathroom to see it) "She said you had a huge cock. Not bad."

"You are never going to be able to have anal sex with that thing" False, fortunately.

"If it's thick like that, shouldn't it be longer?" Kind of a backhanded compliment.

"You could be in porn"

"Why is it so thick?" Uh, I dunno.

Ex-gf . . . this one still cracks me up. "Um, did any of your other girlfriends have trouble going #2 the next day?" She would get constipated (from vaginal not from anal sex). Confusing. She had a very tight vagina and very narrow waist. Everyones built differently.

Same girl "I've never had a bigger one in my mouth or in my . . . longer but not bigger." This was interesting because she had told me about one of her old bf's who she had put her hand on the lower part of his stomach and said "Whats that?" . . .It was his cock, all the way up to his navel (guessing 8" or so). All shapes all sizes right?

Rikter8

Mine were:

"That it?"

"ok.....?"

Or the most memorable - "Well at least I got dinner out of the deal"

Cloud9

I think pretty much everytime is a classic. But probably the most funny was when is was with this one young lady. We had been with each otehr for a few weeks, she was lying on her tummy. As she rose to the doggy position i grabbed her hips, and pressed my head onto her asshole and said in this serious/dominating voice, "Ok now im gonna fuck fuck in the ass bitch!" She spun around the look on her face was priceless! LOL It still makes me laugh. A look of utter terror/disgust/amazement. Of course i told her i was joking, cuddled a bit, and fucked her later..:)

Strider

I'd never posted before but I told the whole story in another thread so I thought I might as well put it in here too!

I was in a steamroom on my own, at least I thought I was, dozing, when a really hot girl who had caught my eye earlier in the evening said (in French), "you should be naked in here, we are in France, you know?" When I opened my eyes I saw she had got rid of her tiny black bikini and was just sitting there, grinning impishly at me, completely naked...

The upshot was I stood up, dropped by trunks and that left her, sitting on the bench, staring straight at my 6inch half-hard. It was literally right in front of her face, she could hardly miss it:

She gasped, her eyes went wide and she put her hand up to her mouth. She didn't comment on it but just kept staring straight at it til I sat back down. Jeez, that was such a turn on! The only one I can remember, I don't think I really take in the reactions--I'll watch for them in future and let you know

PS: Too read the whole story, see the 'skinny dipping stories' thread in the New Member Introductions forum.

chris6092

It's not what they say it's just the sparkle in their eyes that does it for me!

blutrane

I'm 8"x5.5". My current girlfriend has had never seen one before mine, and here was her response:

"Well I'm impressed! I mean, it's not like I have a frame of reference, but I'm IMPRESSED...let's just say it's not what I expected!"

I particularly enjoyed the fact that someone without a frame of reference would still sense that it was big. The other girl before here didn't say anything immediately, but she spread crazy rumors about how "huge" I was.

sometimesomewhere

when i had sex with a girl that i hadn't had sex with since high school.

i had lost about a hundred pounds or so (from 280 to 160) and aged about 5 years since we last fucked and when we undressed, she looked at it and her eyes bugged.

"that's bigger than what i remember!"

that's really the only reaction i ever got. or that i counted as a reaction, at least.

"everybody wants a rock to wind a piece of string around"

Mr. Snakey

Spladle

One time this girl saw me naked and then let me have sex with her!