Best reaction to your size the first time....

lapdog2001

My most memorable one was also with the woman with whom I lost my virginity. She was the first woman to see me 'full size.'

We had been heavy into foreplay and groping and when I lay back so she could use her hands and mouth on me, she just had this 'look' on her face as she stared at my dick, stroking it, and looked me in the eyes.
I said "What?"
She said "You're huge!"

Made my day.

LapDog
100% Heterosexual, 7"+ by 6"

JonahFalcon

It's always "HOLY SHIT!" or some variation, even when they know how big I am already.

captwinky

My favorite was when a girl asked to if I wore underwear (I dont) when I told her no, she abruptly just took it apon herself to unbutton my jeans. She looked at it with wide eyes and said "Now thats what I'm talking about."

Latinoboy9

"If its that big now? How much bigger is it gonna get? Damm Boy!"

monsternmypant

"Where the HELL are you going to put THAT thing?" -- from a hot 19yo Marine I've been

bigone,babe

My wife and I on our honeymoon. We were in the bed and I took off the last thing I had on(these silk red boxers) and out sprung my hard 9.5X4 inch dick. My wife looked at it for over a minute with this cute,sexy astonished face. Afterwards, she mumbled something whilst she still had that look of astonishment. I got on her, started making out with her, and minutes later had her cumming for the very first time with my big dick. AWESOME night.

http://www.sheagunther.org/blog/blog-pix/manbearpig.jpgAl Gore and "manbearpig"

FieldRatt9

Some I remember are... "But...you're not that tall?" ."Is that you?" "Where does it sleep?" "Wow I thought they were lying?!" And the funniest one yet was ... "I thought you were mexican?"

DenBoy

10 minutes into 1st time sex with my ex GF "Wow perfect size perfect technique."

AnonymousToast

First time I made out with my first, current, and only girlfriend:

*kiss* *kiss* *grope* *grope* *eyes go wide* "Damn, boy!" *grin* *grin*

reddog

To all the above posters:

Now, wasn't that great to remember? Not to mention a great source of wank fodder... Come on...you know you did...

Gisella

Nice!

BigPoppaFury

When I was 17 and having trouble getting a condom on (until that point I always thought I was average or small) the girl saying "Im not suprised, fucking size of that".

My friends call me Big Poppa for an entirely different reason, but I've had a few girls say "so THATS why....."

The best was with one ex, the look on her face was astonishment followed simply by "oh my god".

prepky

first time the wife saw it......."now that is gonna hurt"
and she wasnt a virgin either...It didnt really dawn on me until after that she had made that comment

prep

8x 6 uncut in central kentucky that shows a great bulge !!!

reddog

Based on the posts, I'm thinking the most common reaction is wide-eyed and then: f*uck me with that ... followed by legs reaching for the ceiling... Sweet...

hardarms

Never forget...was first time with a girl in a sexual situation. We were both 16 and I was very inexperienced, I'm not sure about the girl. Anyway we were hot making out when she reaches down and grabs me and there is a suprised look on her face. She pulls down my pants, takes a look at me in all my glory, all 8+ thick inches...

She calls me a freak and that I'm not going to put that thing in her. I was as you would expect very disapointed...but she went and told her friends about me and you know it worked out well. In a week a couple of her friends had come and asked to see the huge cock, and I had some real fun for the first time!