I'm cut, and unless my wife's Jewish and/or really seriously demands it for religious reasons I won't do it. I'd definitely fight the above scenario, but I have great respect for religious devotion even though my Catholicism has waned considerably, so if following a laying of evidence and arguments for leaving him intact she insists due to a firmly held religious belief I'd agree to it. Not without a "real" reason though. I have no real issues with my circumcision status, never having been any other way, and I rather like the way my dick and head look without the foreskin, but the reasoning against it is strong and requires a stronger case of belief than "well, it'll be cleaner and the doctors say so."