Originally Posted by mem0101

Since some of the rules for banning appear to be arbitrary, I don't see why letting them back in is a problem.

If all are let back in I don't see a problem, with the exception of continued malicious trolling.

Maybe a ban should be a one year ban. After that a permanent ban. Second time's the charm.

Now, if some odd fish comes back after they have been banned, and gets caught again, they should stay out.