How Big is BIG ??

HotCock007: Hi All, I am a new member (LOL!). No pun intended ! But as it happens my wife and I are keen to find out, especially from females, just how big is considered big?

chicago_girl: I consider 8 inches or more big.

Hi folks...and welcome to the lpsg.

You have a great, appropriate question here...but there is a similar thread (or two?) in previous pages...'may take a bit of research but lots of prior responses including "how big is Too big" and so on.

My take on"big" would obviously begin with a measurement over the average size of typically all (ahem) official (?) surveys (or those we dare know about) which lists average flaccid length at 3 1/2" to 4";
average erect length 5 1/2" to 6" with erect girth
at about 4.5" to 5". From there...YOU pretty much decide for yourself on what YOU believe or how YOU feel
about the matter based on personal tastes, desires,expereience, etc. (and will ultimately hear MANY opinions as to what size is really "big") Hence, life here at the lpsg. As I said, welcome! and--Happy reading!
:)

AnonyMs: It is a combination of length and girth. A 10 inch "pencil" penis is not going to solicit the same sort of awe a 7.5 x 7.5 might.

BIG is a very subjective term. For some, big = 'larger than average'. Others have told me that I'm 'not so big' because my cock doesn't exceed 10". Hung Jury and Inches magazine classified any cock 8+" to be big. I guess big is whatever seems big in your eyes. Fair enough?

HotCock007: Hey everyone! Thanks for the replies, all of them were great and much appreciated by us both ! Just as we both thought the concept of big and Big seems to be a very individual and subjective concept. Once again, Thanks!

mr17yearold: big also has alot to do with your height and body type... a short skinny guy's dick will look alot bigger than if he was really tall and/or really fat... so like DMW said, big is very subjective

SissyCouple: Well mine is 5 3/4", 5 1/2" around. Lots of girls say it is big.

balls: I didn’t have a lot of experience before I got married and my wife only slept with one other guy. So I was wondering, what would most of you consider a 7.25x5.75 erect penis? I know for this group it is probably below average but compared to others, outside the group, where do you think it would be? Would it be average, above average, big, is it a nice size, length, girth?
I really am just curious, chalk it up to my lack of experience.

prepstudinsc: I think thickness has a lot to do with what is considered big. I get told that my thickness is more impressive than the length. I guess that the average thickness is fairly thin. One of my friends who saw me hard told me that my bone looked like a baby's leg. lol

I've got a friend who is about 8" long but is about 5" around. His is long, but thin. I've got another friend who is about 6.5" long but about 6" around. Who has the bigger dick? Each of my friends is big in a different way, but I think it's the combination of length and thickness that constitutes "big" rather than longer than average or thicker than average.

Maybe I'm splitting hairs over this, but it's just my two cents worth.....

AnonyMs: [quote author=balls link=board=sex;num=1043144584;start=0#8 date=01/22/03 at 0730]So I was wondering, what would most of you consider a 7.25x5.75 erect penis? [/quote] If I were with a man that size and were mentioning his studliness to my GFs, I would say something along the lines of, "He is on the large size."

Be happy and confident with what you have...

aj2181: [quote author=mr17yearold link=board=sex;num=1043144584;start=0#6 date=01/22/03 at 05:26:22]big also has alot to do with your height and body type... a short skinny guy's dick will look alot bigger than if he was really tall and/or really fat... so like DMW said, big is very subjective[/quote]

Thats true. Most people say my cock is very large (11.5x7) I would agree. But I'm 6 feet 10 inches tall and have a large athletic body type (not a toothpic) and my penis dosn't apear to be as large.

bklynbigballs: I had a friend who was an escort. I never saw him naked so I can't verify, but he told me that he tells his clients he has an eight and a half inch cock but in reality he only has 7.2" He said that his cock "looks big" and that he's never had a client say to him, "that's not eight inches!" Apparently "eight" is considered the magic number and as long as your cock looks "big", you can get away with being "eight." But if you say "Nine" or "Ten" your client will expect a horsecock.

I was also reading Sydney Biddle Barrows's bio -- the Mayflower Madam -- and she said that her clients would ask for a girl who was "36-24-36" and she'd just send over anyone who was attractive and curvy and they'd never complain.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to make one of those "size doesn't matter" arguments. I'm just pointing out that I've seen a lot of big cocks and I couldn't tell you what they all measured, I just knew they were big.

What I consider big:

When I have trouble fitting it into my mouth
When I can't stop staring at it.
When I want to suck it even though it's attached to a not-so-attractive person
When his back is turned to me in the lockerroom and I can still see it between his legs.

mr17yearold: aj2181, 11.5"x7" is huge, no matter how big u are man... no joke... thats a fing monster cock :o

mr17yearold: i know im posting one post right after another post... my bad

anyway, i was thinking about a way to determine if your big mathematically... and here is what i came up with.

(larger than ave.) - (big)
min. l - min. g - total (l+g) - total (l+g)
5' - 5" 5" 11" 12"
5'3" - 5" 5" 11.5" 12.5"
5'6" - 5.5" 5" 12" 13"
5'9" - 5.5" 5" 12" 13"
6' - 6" 5.5" 12.5" 13.5"
6'3" - 6" 5.5" 13" 14"
6'6" - 6.5" 5.5" 13" 14"
6'9" - 6.5" 5.5" 13.5" 14.5"
7'+ - 7"+ 6"+ 13.5" 15"

i dont know if it will line up when i post it... and if there is anything that needs clarification, please ask... also... if there are values that should be change... ask.

l=length g=girth ave=average min.=minimum
total means your length and girth have to add up to that number... minimum l or g means your length or girth has to be at least that big.